• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • About The Charity Report
    • Editorial
    • The Charity Report: Frequently Asked Questions
  • Bespoke Research About Charities
  • Contact The Charity Report
  • Log In

The Charity Report

... creating a space that gets people talking

Shop Intelligence Reports
  • Photo Essay
  • Reports and Features
  • News
  • Headlines
  • Literary Circle
    • Literary Circle Review Panel
  • Book Shop
  • TalkingUP Podcast

Reform the charitable sector senator urges government

Senator Ratna Omidvar

(September 9, 2020) With the installation of new finance minister Chrystia Freeland, Senator Ratna Omidvar is renewing her call to reform the charitable sector. 

Senator Omidvar was the deputy chair of the Special Senate Committee on the Charity Sector, which ran from January 2018 until it issued a report in June 2019. The role of the committee was to examine the impact of federal and provincial laws and policies governing charities, nonprofit organizations, foundations, and other similar groups. 

 “The WE controversy is a lift off point to illustrate the urgent need to reform the charitable sector including modernizing regulations around earned revenue for charities as well as diversifying board governance,” she said.

“If anything,” Omidvar wrote in a Toronto Star op-ed, “the WE affair has displayed the urgent need for a hard look at the sector.” 

She says charities need to be supported in developing their governance capacity in order to ensure transparency and accountability, that charities should reflect the diversity of Canada and that we need to collect data on diversity to get a better information on governance. 

“There are only three sources of revenue for charities—charitable donations, government grants and earned revenue,” she wrote in Policy Options magazine on September 8. “Of the three, only earned revenue is forecasted to grow. It is not realistic for us to starve charities of the only revenue stream that can stabilize their financial future.”

Even in the wake of the WE charity controversy where “there are at least five or six different organizations that have been setup to do distinctly different but associated things,” she believes the re-drafting of 50-year old regulations must be undertaken to make it easier for charities to “enable charities to generate revenue from unrelated businesses.”

Imagine Canada, a lobby group for philanthropy sector testified in front of the senate committee saying that, [“W]ith constraints emerging and demand increasing, charities are going to need to be able to explore every funding opportunity available to them. Out of government funding, philanthropy and earned income, only the last one offers any prospect of long-term growth, and it’s a constrained alternative.

In the current system charities who want to generate earned revenue have to set up an arms-length organization which can flow net revenue through to a charity. But the rules governing this process are strict and the costs are “a deterrent to charities looking for new sources of revenue,” says Omidvar.

The senator contends that the reason charity sector is saddled with “outmoded laws and regulations that hinder their ability to deliver on their charitable mission … is because no government has paid any attention to the sector as a whole.”

She calls it a “sign of the benign neglect that the charitable sector has suffered.” 

In other jurisdictions, such as Australia, steps have been undertaken to build the capacity of the charity sector, improve its impact and provide relevant regulation.  The Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission Act (ACNC) was established in 2012 with the following objectives: 

  • maintain, protect and enhance public trust and confidence in the Australian not-for-profit sector
  • support and sustain a robust, vibrant, independent and innovative not-for-profit sector
  • promote the reduction of unnecessary regulatory obligations on the sector

It’s website is host to a wide range of resources for charities and it created a Charity Passport. The Charity Passport uses a ‘report once, use often’ philosophy, which “reduces the amount of information that charities must provide to different government agencies.”

In 2019, the government announced the creation of the post of Assistant Minister for Finance, Charities and Electoral Matters, a position will include oversight of the ACNC.

Best practices exist. Canada might do well to look beyond its borders to another Commonwealth country for guidance on to reform the charity sector as opposed to tinkering with the system we have.

Filed Under: News Tagged With: Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission, Ratna Omidvar, Reform the charitable sector

Primary Sidebar

Literary Circle Reviews

Heroin: What came first—the suffering or the criminalization?

June 20, 2022 By Literary Circle

The Smart NonProfit : Staying Human-Centred in an Automated World 

June 20, 2022 By Literary Circle

Is America’s next civil war already in progress?

March 14, 2022 By Literary Circle

Nora Loreto and her book Spin Doctors are here to tell us how we got here

January 24, 2022 By Literary Circle

Cid Brunet, A Stripper’s Memoir: One woman’s tour through humankind

December 20, 2021 By Literary Circle

Wayne Simpson: Photos of the human soul

December 16, 2021 By Literary Circle

  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Footer

About

Our beat is justice and equity in the charity sector. We follow news of the day, highlight people doing amazing work and conduct new research that sheds light on the forces driving the sector. The Charity Report TalkingUP podcast, hosted by editor in chief Gail Picco, interviews authors and journalists wbo have lots to say about the issues facing our time.  This is a place where independent thinking is valued, questions about the charity sector are asked and our independence is fiercely guarded. The guardians of that space are our Subscribers and Patrons who provide the financial support to pay writers, editors, researchers, producers, and content providers. We adore them.

Learn more.

Recent

  • The Charity Report Ceases Publication 
  • The Cost of Conflict: How we measure the global failure in Syria
  • Where Wealth Resides: The funding of philanthropy in Canada
  • Who Give and Who Gets: The Beneficiaries of Private Foundation Philanthropy
  • Community Giving: The Growth and Giving Priorities of Community Foundations

Search

Copyright © 2023 The Charity Report · Log in